The Victorian government's AI-powered road safety initiative has come under fire, and for good reason. The Distracted Driver and Seatbelt Detection Program, launched with great fanfare in 2023, has failed to deliver on its promises, according to a scathing audit. This program, which aimed to reduce road accidents, serious injuries, and deaths, has instead left a trail of questions and concerns.
The Victorian Auditor-General's Office (VAGO) report, which analyzed 308 camera sites, 160,754 camera hours, and 188,493 infringements, paints a picture of a program in disarray. The report found that the Department of Justice and Community Safety, responsible for the program, does not have a clear understanding of its impact on road safety. They admit they don't know if the program is reducing accidents, injuries, and deaths, and they haven't even gathered the necessary data to make an informed comparison. This is a shocking revelation, especially considering the program's hefty price tag of $28.3 million.
One of the most concerning findings is the lack of evidence for camera positioning. Victoria Police, tasked with identifying camera sites, doesn't always record its decisions consistently. This means they can't always demonstrate that their choices are based on sound evidence, raising questions about the program's effectiveness and fairness. Moreover, the audit uncovered privacy breaches, with the archiving software used by Jenoptik, the camera operator, found to be in breach of regulations. This not only highlights a failure in data protection but also calls into question the integrity of the entire program.
The report's implications are far-reaching. It suggests that the program's success is uncertain, and the government's claims about its benefits are unsubstantiated. This is particularly concerning given the rising road death toll in Victoria. The number of deaths increased by 55.6% in April 2026 compared to the previous year, and by 0.3% over the past 12 months. This trend is a stark reminder that the program's intended impact on road safety has not been realized.
The audit also highlights the need for better record-keeping and data collection. The Department of Justice and Community Safety has changed its expected outcomes and hasn't consistently reported on the program's performance. This makes it difficult to assess the program's progress and hold it accountable. The report recommends improvements in measuring and reporting, which is a crucial step towards ensuring the program's effectiveness and transparency.
In my opinion, this audit is a wake-up call for the Victorian government. It's time to reevaluate the program's strategy, enhance data collection, and ensure the integrity of the camera system. The public deserves to know if their tax dollars are being spent effectively to improve road safety. The government must take immediate action to address these concerns and demonstrate a commitment to transparency and accountability. Otherwise, the program's legacy may be one of wasted resources and unfulfilled promises.
